OK, so I opened both of the recipes (renaming one to allow the program to open it up without overwriting the other). When I looked at the brew steps txt report, it clearly showed the issue with the recipe containing the TFMO having a much lower infusion volume. I checked out the mash tab and in both recipes the mash tab showed the same initial infusion volume. I looked at the TFMO versus the MOPA, no issues there. Looked at the first infusion step for the water to grain ratio and found them to be equal. Saved the recipes back (even though I did not make any changes) and the water infusion is now equal. Both recipes read the same.
I cannot tell you what corrected the issue, but something I looked into seemed to reset whatever was making the water volumes come out wonky.